My rating: 5 stars
Can a dark and twisted novel be absolutely beautiful? The Dumb House by John Burnside proves that it is possible. Although the story being told utterly shocked me, it also left me in awe of the way words were exquisitely put together. So, I was completely immersed in the story, being both marvelled and shaken to my core at the same time.
The story is narrated in the first person by Luke (whose name is only mentioned more than halfway through the novel). When he was a child his mother told him the story of the Dumb House. According to the tale, a dyslexic emperor named Akbar the Mughal ordered a mansion to be built. There he kept new-born babies attended by people who were dumb. The purpose of such an experiment was to test if language was either innate or learnt.
Luke developed an obsession not only with this topic, but also with the question of life and death, and the existence of a soul. Even as a child he performed experiments on small animals by dissecting them. His obsession deepens to the point of him later performing experiments on his own children. The story starts with him mentioning this fact and then goes back in time to explain how he got to that point.
Throughout the narration, he mentions many episodes that took place during his childhood. His relationship with his parents was quite strange, and he also seems to have developed a kind of obsession with his mother, calling her always “Mother” with a capital letter. On the other hand, he remembers his father with contempt and as inferior in comparison with him and his mother.
The way the story is told mirrors, in a certain way, the tale of the Dumb House, as it has both a dark and a beautiful side. One thing that is noted by the narrator is that the tale told to him by his mother had beautiful descriptions of the place where the babies were kept, although what interested him was the experiment being performed. In the same way, this book is beautifully written, having great metaphors and comparisons, such as “my skin was stretched tight as a drum”. However, what Luke made to the babies and what the other characters who crossed his path had to endure is horrific.
The best way to describe The Dumb House is to call it a psychological horror. This was a book that got me emotionally attached. So, I definitely want to read more by John Burnside in the future and see if his other books are just as good.